전편에서 윌리(빌리 밥 손튼)와 마커스(토니 콕스)는 크리스마스 시즌이 되면 산타와 엘프 복장으로 변장하고 밤에 쇼핑몰을 털고 다닌다. 하지만 알콜중독이자 성중독자인 윌리가 갈수록 문제를 일으키면서 마커스와 갈등을 빚는다. 급기야 마커스는 경찰에 체포되지만 윌리는 순진한 아이 서먼(브렛 켈리) 덕분에 감옥 신세를 면한다.
Dare to be square! In a world where "The only good pumpkins are round pumpkins!" SPOOKLEY THE SQUARE PUMPKIN is often teased by the other pumpkins because of his odd shape. Soon, Spookley is befriended by Edgar, Allan and Poe, three hilarious spiders, who convince Spookley that square or not, he has a right to be the "Pick of the Patch" on Halloween. "A square pumpkin the Pick of the Patch?" Not if mean round pumpkins Big Tom and Little Tom can help it. These two bullies tease and taunt Spookley because of his square roots. Encouraged to continue to become the "Pick of the Patch" by kindly Jack the Scarecrow and his bat sidekicks, Boris and Bella, Spookley isn't sure he has what it takes until a mighty storm threatens to destroy the entire patch. As the storm rolls the round pumpkins uncontrollably across the patch towards the raging river, Spookley realizes "it's fine to be round while the weather is fair, but there are times it's better to be a square!"
