From their first encounter as teenagers in high school, Scott and Sid seem unlikely friends. Scott is a shambolic dreamer, intent on carving out his own path in life and holding up a metaphorical middle finger to anyone who tries to stop him. He is a quintessential troubled teen: on his fifth high school by the age of fifteen, alienated from his peers, crippled by recurring nightmares and disliked by his own foster parents. Sid, on the other hand, wants nothing more than to be liked. An unconfident, awkward recluse through circumstance, Sid's impoverished and dysfunctional background leave him no time for friends and no money for hobbies.
O desaparecimento de pessoas em uma pequena cidade do Alasca desperta a atenção de um estudioso, que acaba misteriosamente assassinado. Sua esposa, a psicóloga Abigail Tyler, passa a observar evidências de abdução alienígena por meio de filmagens obtidas durante sessões com seus pacientes. Após outro caso de morte, o xerife August passa a considerá-la suspeita, dando início a um intrigante e assustador jogo de perguntas e respostas sobre deuses e alienígenas através das sessões de hipnose.