Dennis and Henry are neighbors and both married their high school sweethearts. When they both get divorced at the same time for different reasons, Henry and Dennis lives turn upside down as they get back into the dating world and on with their lives after they receive a To-Do list from an old friend.
Ave María Mulligan ha vivido toda su vida en Big Stone Gap, un pintoresco pueblo minero enclavado en los Montes Apalaches del suroeste de Virginia. Autoproclamada soltera, Ana María rehace su vida y la cambia para siempre tras enterarse de un secreto familiar, flirtea con el chico de quien siempre ha estado enamorada y se muestra expectante ante la visita de la estrella Elizabeth Taylor a Big Stone Gap.
